Mission & Name
US Foreign Policy (Dr. El-Najjar's Articles)
Baskin's Generous Offer:
Making Peace with Israeli Occupation
By Ramzy Baroud
Al-Jazeerah, CCUN, June 6, 2015
It would be fair to assume that Gershon Baskin’s recent article
in the Jerusalem Post -
Encountering Peace: Obviously no peace now, so what then? (June 24) – is
not a mere intellectual exercise aimed at finding ‘creative’ solutions to
the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
Baskin is a regular
contributor to the Jerusalem Post, a rightwing newspaper. He is more or less
embodied in the Israeli political establishment, otherwise, he would have
never been allowed to initiate the “secret back channel for the release (of
captured Israeli soldier) Gilad Schalit” as he proudly states in his bio.
In the article, Baskin offers a way to manage the Israeli
occupation of the West Bank and Jerusalem. Not an end to the occupation, but
a gentler way to sustain it, if not profit from it. The co-chairman of
‘Israel Palestine Creative Regional Initiatives’ is indeed being ‘creative’,
the kind of creativity that brought about the Village Leagues, Oslo and the
Geneva Initiative without truly delving into the heart of the matter – the
illegality and brutality of Israel’s occupation, sieges and wars.
Baskin’s reading of the situation is quite bleak. He carefully tries not to
place any responsibility on any side for the lack of any political horizon,
as a way to gain credibility. “Neither side seems to be particularly
interested in escalation and violence,” he wrote, reaching a puzzling
conclusion that seems at odd with reality, at least Palestinian reality:
“Noteworthy is the sense that the young people on both sides have of being
more interested in their daily lives than in national causes.”
is not entirely certain how the daily lives of ‘Israeli youth’, who serve in
the very military that is dedicated to subduing ‘Palestinian youth’ are in
But that aside, Baskin has a solution, one that
requires a degree of flexibility on the part of the Israeli government, to
show more leniency in the way it manages its occupation of the Palestinians.
Baskin calls on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to take the
initiative of making border areas places of trade and economic exchanges,
and to make the permit system required of Palestinian to move about in their
own occupied land more efficient.
Just in case, one would conflate
Baskin’s imitative with
Netanyahu’s gambit in 2008-09 of ‘economic peace’ – aimed largely at
maintaining the profitable occupation, subduing the Palestinians and
avoiding any political accountability – Baskin calls on Netanyahu to “be
careful not to use concepts like ‘economic peace’ which are immediately
interpreted as a means to replace ‘political peace,’ meaning the end of the
occupation and the creation of a Palestinian state.”
be no spin and no lies. There is no chance of negotiating peace now, so
let’s see what can be done to improve the lives of people until there is a
chance of making peace,” he wrote, more or less the same guiding principles
behind Netanyahu’s ‘economic
Interestingly, the word settlements (as in ‘illegal
settlements’ as designated by international law) is not mentioned by Baskin.
Not once. And knowing of Netanyahu’s adamant position on the continued
expansion of the illegal settlements, Baskin’s omission of the topic
altogether must also mean that his proposal is not pre-conditioned on ending
or at least freezing the theft of Palestinian land for settlement
Another omission is that of any references to
international law, and the Fourth Geneva Convention in particular. By
treating Palestinians with respect (the ‘inefficiency’ at the Qalanidya
checkpoint was Baskin’s main example) is not a favor that is to be bestowed
by Netanyahu and his army, but has been long articulated in the
Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of
Article 50, for example, reads, “The Occupying Power
shall, with the cooperation of the national and local authorities,
facilitate the proper working of all institutions devoted to the care and
education of children.”
By ceasing to target Palestinian children,
whether through arrests or violence, Israel would hardly be extending a hand
for peace or co-existence. In other words, what Baskin is asking for by way
to manage the Israeli occupation, is a requirement by international law that
should have been put in place decades ago, as a prerequisite to ending the
Also not mentioned in Baskin’s ‘so what then?’
initiative is Gaza, whose children have been starved and killed with
impunity throughout 9 years of a protracted and heinous siege that is only
interrupted by deadly and more heinous Israeli wars. The
latest UN report on Israel’s war on Gaza in 2014 leaves no doubt that
Netanyahu, and his governments hadn’t the slightest intentions of honoring
international law, respecting UN conventions on children or civilians during
time of war, or reaching any political settlements, not now or ever.
But why did Baskin neglect Gaza altogether? It cannot be that the man who
wrote and profited from a book about his Gaza-related adventures called,
“The Negotiator: Freeing Gilad Schalit from Hamas”, failed to understand the
centrality of the Gaza siege to the overall Palestinian national discourse.
So what is really behind Baskin’s supposed bold proposal?
Baskin is very close to those in power. His initiatives are rarely his own,
and the latest is a mere reflection of the political
bankruptcy of Netanyahu’s government.
Baskin is, of course
wrong. Palestinians have shown much willingness to end the conflict in a
method that hinges on Israel’s respect for international law, including the
ending of the construction of illegal settlements.
Netanyahu’s government is stacked with more rightwing zealots - individuals
who made careers and gained famed and notoriety, because of their insistence
on the maintaining of the occupation, and feeding off, politically and
financially, the illegal settlements - a return to the ‘negotiation table’
Meanwhile, the Palestinian Authority of Mahmoud
Abbas, is finding itself in an impossible situation; whereas, on one hand it
is reaping the ample benefits of being the caretaker government of an
imagined ‘authority’, itself under Israeli occupation, and on the other, it
is having to seek international recognition of a Palestinian state, a matter
that is most upsetting for Israel.
Moreover, the United States,
which seems to have given up on persuading Netanyahu to reengage in the
‘peace process’, has now moved on to more pressing matters in the region,
which balances are more fractious than ever before.
The US is also
mellowing down, at least for now, with its obsession with the perceived
Iranian nuclear threat. If an agreement is reached between Iran and the US
and its allies, then Israel would have no other option but to find
another enemy to justify its military belligerence and heightened sense
of political urgency.
Indeed, that new enemy is being quickly
Israeli President Reuven Rivlin, Prime Minister Netanyahu, and powerful
US-based Zionists such as
seem to all agree that the non-violent civil society-empowered movement:
BDS, aimed at boycotting, divestment and sanctioning Israel, is Israel’s
While Israel gears up for its new ‘existential’ battle
against civil society organizations, it’s keen on normalizing the occupation
of Palestine. This is why the ‘economic peace’ formula keeps resurfacing
every now and then, the latest being Baskin’s elucidation.
peace is not war, and Baskin should know that not a single past formula
aimed at fashioning a ‘peaceful’ military occupation has ever worked. He
also ought to remember that the so-called golden age of the Israeli
occupation was precisely that few years that preceded the First Palestinian
Uprising in 1987. It was then that all hell broke loose.
- Dr. Ramzy
Baroud has been writing about the Middle East for over 20 years. He is an
internationally-syndicated columnist, a media consultant, an author of
several books and the founder of PalestineChronicle.com. His latest book is
My Father Was a Freedom Fighter: Gaza’s Untold Story (Pluto Press, London).
His website is: ramzybaroud.net.
Share this article with your facebook friends