Mission & Name
US Foreign Policy (Dr. El-Najjar's Articles)
After Egypt: Arab Voices Matter
By James Zogby
Al-Jazeerah, CCUN, February 15, 2011
If one lesson is to be learned from the remarkable events unfolding
in Egypt, it is that Arab public opinion matters. For too long Arab voices
have not been listened to, nor have Arab sensibilities or aspirations been
respected. The Egyptian people have not only risen up, demanding to be
heard, they have challenged other Arabs and the West to pay attention to
what they are saying.
On Thursday night I watched a remarkable scene
unfolding on television. As my dinner partner, Patrick Seale, and I sat
transfixed watching the BBC, there, on one half of a split screen, was
President Hosni Mubarak making a last ditch effort to save his rule. On the
other half screen were throngs in Tahrir Square. The disconnect was so real.
Mubarak was talking, but he simply wasn't listening. He played every card at
his disposal: the caring father, the patriot, the xenophobe, the reformer
and more. Maybe, I thought, he was reaching out beyond the Square to those
he thought might also be listening. But if his imagined and hoped for
audience was there, they were not responding. The crowd in the Square was
listening and his lack of responsiveness to their concerns only served to
inflame them and deepen their resolve.
It was the immovable object
squaring off against the irresistible force. In the end, the force won. The
protesters rejected Mubarak's promises and his appeals as "too little, too
late," and began to pour out beyond the Square to take new space and
demonstrate their discontent.
Now the president is gone. The throngs
have won this round and they are empowered to seek more change. It is not
the end, just the beginning of a process, the outcome of which is still
uncertain. With the military in charge, it will now be up to them to listen.
Questions remain. Will the military cede space and open the political
process to real reform? Will they be more responsive to the growing
aspirations of their young who are demanding: jobs in an expanding economy
where wealth is shared; an opportunity to participate in the shaping of the
future of their country; and the freedom to express their discontent with
and seek to change policies they find deplorable, without fear of
In some ways, after February 11th, much has changed. In
other ways, the struggle remains the same. A movement that has won a round
now becomes a potentially formidable force. But a regime that fears losing
control is also a force which must be reckoned with. In the weeks and months
ahead we will see this drama play out in the streets and in negotiations.
The constitution must be changed. President Mubarak has promised as much.
The concerns of the demonstrators have been acknowledged by the military,
who have said they are listening. Now we will see if they, in fact, were.
The problem of not listening to Arab voices is not only a problem for
those Presidents who have fallen or those who are still at risk; it is a
problem for the West, as well. For too long, the U.S., Great Britain, and
others have ignored the concerns and sensibilities of Arab people. Arabs
have been treated as if they were pawns to be moved about on the board.
While we paid attention to our own needs and politics, Arabs were left to
make do or accommodate themselves to realities we created for them, as we
sought to protect our interests, not theirs.
This is not a
new phenomenon. The cavalier dismissal of Arab voices began with Lord
Balfour who famously rejected the first survey of Arab opinion, conducted
for U.S. President Woodrow Wilson at the end of World War I. While the
survey found Arabs overwhelming rejecting the European powers' plans to
carve up the Arab East into British and French mandatory entities, and the
creation of a Jewish National Home in Palestine, Balfour balked saying "we
do not propose even to go through the form of consulting the wishes of the
present inhabitants of the country... Zionism, be it right or wrong, good or
bad...is of far greater import than the desire and prejudices of the Arabs
who now inhabit that ancient land.”
As blatant as that rejection was,
this practice of ignoring Arab concerns did not end. Until this day, all too
often the West has acted across the Middle East as if Arabs were objects
without sensibilities or concerns. We invaded Iraq without understanding the
impact this might have on Arab opinion. We have continued to ignore
Palestinian suffering and aspirations (recall Condolezza Rice's dismissal of
the plight and rights of Palestinian refugees with a casual "bad things
happen in history"). And we have engaged in wide-spread profiling and other
forms of deplorable treatment of Arabs and Muslims, paying no attention to
the toll that these and other wildly unpopular policies were having on the
legitimacy of Arab governments who were our friends and allies.
Now all this must of necessity change. When the Egyptian people
organized themselves demanding to be heard they introduced a new and
potentially transformative factor into the political equation of the region.
It will no longer be possible to operate as if Arab public opinion doesn't
matter. It will no longer possible to act as if policies can be imposed and
blindly accepted. No longer will we be able to consider only the Israeli
internal debate or the consequences on Israeli opinion in our calculations.
Arabs have been inspired by Egypt and empowered to believe that their voices
must be heard and respected. It will make life more complicated for Western
and some Arab policy makers. But if this complication is a good thing and it
represents change, that has been a long time coming. As President Obama
said, this is just the beginning and after today, nothing will be same. The
reality is that this transformation will not only affect Egypt. The change
that is coming will be bigger than any of us can imagine.