The rush to
war
By Firas Al-Atraqchi
YellowTimes.org
-
There is a
maddening rush to war that is unparalleled in recent human history. There
are many reasons why the phrase "rush to war" is apt in
describing the current socio-political environment. However, the rush has
little to nothing to do with the fact that Iraq has allegedly not disarmed
in 12 years, or that Iraq has allegedly flaunted 17 United Nations
Security Council resolutions. War pundits and the cabal behind the war
machine continue to argue that "Saddam has had plenty of time to
disarm." We hear phrases from U.S. National Security Adviser
Condoleezza Rice that "enough is enough," that "Saddam is
toying with the inspectors as he routinely has done in the past
decade."
However, while the Bush administration persistently refers to the past 12
years, there is no mention of the next 12 years. Who will run Iraq? What
will Iran do about a U.S. military force in Iraq? What happens to the
world economy if Saddam destroys Iraq's oil fields? How much will the war
cost? Who will clean up the mess? What of the irradiated uranium shells
and casings littering the battlefield in Gulf War I? If 80,000 U.S.
military personnel have "mysterious ailments" as a result of the
first Gulf War, what does that imply about the impending conflict? Will
Iraqi Shiites rebel? Will the Kurds declare an independent state? Will
Turkey invade the north while Iran invades the south? How does this play
into Osama bin Laden's "conspiracy against Islam" theory? What
role does the opposition Iraqi National Congress play in a new Iraq?
None of
these questions have been answered. All we hear from the likes of Richard
Perle, Paul Wolfowitz et al, is that once Iraq becomes a democracy, the
rest will follow.
To the
informed Middle East analyst, the above sounds like a comic scene from A
Midsummer Night's Dream.
In recent
days several "events" may paint a picture of how impractical
this drive to war really is.
1. Tension
builds in northern Iraq:
On February
18, an Iranian-backed Iraqi heavy mechanized division of Iraqi troops
under the guidance of Iraqi Shiite Cleric Ayatollah Mohammed Baqir Al-Hakim
crossed into northern Iraq, near the village of Darbandikhan. "The
Badr brigade has been trained and equipped by Iran's Revolutionary Guards
and could be regarded as a proxy force of the Iranian government. Analysts
close to the administration of President George W. Bush said the U.S. was
concerned about the intentions of this new element in an increasingly
complicated patchwork of forces in northern Iraq," the Financial
Times reports.
Most
readers have never heard of Al-Hakim, nor are they aware that he is very
influential among Iraqi Shiite opposition groups. The fact that he is
fervently supported by Iran indicates that Iran is indirectly telling the
world that it wants a role to play in the future of Iraq.
Turkish
Prime Minister Abdullah Gul announced on February 19 that Turkish military
units will occupy northern Iraq to prevent Iraqi Kurds from declaring an
independent state. According to Reuters news agency, "Turkish
generals want broad freedom to act in northern Iraq to protect a
Turkish-speaking minority and prevent any moves by Kurds to form an
independent state out of the chaos of a war."
The Kurds,
however, have protested to the Turkish presence in northern Iraq and have
vowed to resist it. According to ArabNews.com "the chairman of the
Kurdistani Democratic Party, Masoud al-Barazani, has expressed total
rejection of any Turkish military interference in northern Iraq."
Northern
Iraq also hosts the Mujahideen Khalq (MKO), a heavily armed Iranian
military opposition group fighting to overthrow the Muslim clerics in
Iran. Al-Hakim's forces have vowed to pursue the MKO throughout Iraq.
Ansar-al-Islam, an Islamic militant group ideologically tied to al-Qaeda,
also has an organized military unit in the north of Iraq. Other Kurdish
factions in northern Iraq include the PKK, a militant group bitterly
opposed to Turkish control of Turkish Kurdistan; 34,000 Turks and Kurds
have died in the ensuing conflict since 1984. PKK leader Abdullah Ocalan
is currently incarcerated in a Turkish jail.
The Iraqi
army has mobilized 11 divisions to northern Iraq and has heavily fortified
the ancient city of Mosul. Possible U.S. military scenarios include
launching an attack from Turkey using 40,000 troops.
With so
many forces, all bitter enemies of one another, fortifying positions in
northern Iraq, the situation is akin to a lit powder keg.
The U.S.
has apparently also dispensed with the once friendly Iraqi opposition.
Stark differences remain between the INC vision of a future Iraq and
current plans to install a U.S. military governor in Iraq (likely General
Thomas Franks).
According
to London's Times, "Ahmad Chalabi, the head of the Iraqi National
Congress, complained that Washington was planning to stay in control of
Iraq after President Saddam Hussein had been driven from power and was
even considering keeping in place parts of the existing regime."
2. The
financial equation:
February
21: Reserve Bank of Australia board member Warwick McKibbin and Center for
International Economics executive director Andrew Stoeckel conducted a
study outlining the cost of conflict in Iraq: "A short war with Iraq
could cost the world one percent of its economic output over the next few
years and more than $1 trillion by 2010, Australian researchers said in a
report Thursday."
Another
Australian research outfit had more depressing news: "A protracted
war with Iraq could cut 2 percent from global growth by 2005 and cost
major economies up to US$3.6 trillion by 2010, almost half coming at the
expense of the United States," says the Center for International
Economics in Canberra, Australia.
And that's
the good news. If Iraqi forces carry out a plan to blow up Iraqi oil
fields and refineries, rebuilding Iraq's oil infrastructure could rocket
to 300 billion dollars. In the interim, oil markets would be void of Iraqi
oil, and Iraq would not be generating any revenue to feed its people.
Sixty-five percent of the Iraqi people currently depend on handouts and
rationing from the Iraqi army. Although rationing has kept food and oil
prices very low, ordinary Iraqis have no other source of sustenance.
The World
Health Organization (WHO) recently estimated that an invasion of Iraq
would likely knock out vital water filtration plants and re-introduce
typhoid and cholera. Sewage would clog up the streets of Baghdad and
Iraqis would be left without water until the plants are refitted or
rebuilt. However, if Iraqi oil fields have been blown up, there will be no
revenue to fund such initiatives.
Where will
the money come from? The U.S. is already facing a record deficit, the
stock markets are in decline, U.S. taxpayers have to cough up billions of
dollars to buyout Turkish "alliance and support," and oil prices
are nearing the 40-dollars-a-barrel mark.
3. The
humanitarian equation:
The WHO, as
outlined in the BBC, estimates that 500,000 Iraqis will be killed,
wounded, and/or be inflicted with disease and harm as a direct result of a
war in Iraq. U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan has also informed the
Security Council that, "Nearly half of the Iraqi population may be
left without food or water in the aftermath of a war against the
country." The U.N. has estimated that it is in an 80 million dollar
shortfall in meeting an Iraqi crisis.
The U.N.
has also called on countries bordering Iraq to keep their borders open for
an expected flood of at least one million Iraqi civilians.
Let's not
forget the psychological trauma ordinary Iraqis are currently facing, both
as a result of 12 years of U.N. sanctions and the fear of imminent war.
London's
Independent reported last week that "A team of international
investigators -- including two of the world's foremost psychologists --
have conducted the first pre-conflict field research with children and
concluded that Iraqi children are already suffering 'significant
psychological harm' from the threat of war. The team was welcomed into the
homes of more than 100 Iraqi families where they found the overwhelming
message to be one of fear and the thought of being killed. Many live in a
news void, with little information concerning the heightened threat of
war."
Trafficking
in women, also known as white slavery, will also be introduced into Iraq
as a result of a war. "Without a doubt you will find women who will
be brought in to service the warriors as well as the peacekeepers in these
operations," Michele Clark, co-director of the Protection Project of
Johns Hopkins Foreign Policy Institute, recently reported.
Meanwhile,
CBS recently reported that UNMOVIC inspectors in Iraq had found U.S.
intelligence on suspected Iraqi efforts to hide illicit weapons and
research worthless. "So frustrated have the inspectors become that
one source has referred to the U.S. intelligence they've been getting as
'garbage after garbage after garbage.' In fact, Phillips says the source
used another cruder word. The inspectors find themselves caught between
the Iraqis, who are masters at the weapons-hiding shell game, and the
United States, whose intelligence they've found to be circumstantial,
outdated or just plain wrong," said the CBS report.
[Firas Al-Atraqchi,
B.Sc (Physics), M.A. (Journalism and Communications), is a Canadian
journalist with eleven years of experience covering Middle East issues,
oil and gas markets, and the telecom industry.]
Firas Al-Atraqchi
encourages your comments: fatraqchi@YellowTimes.org