http://www.aljazeerah.info                                    October 26, 2002 News

الجزيرة

News Archives 

Arab Cartoonists

Columnists

Documents

Editorials 

Opinion Editorials

letters to the editor

Human Price of the Israeli Occupation of Palestine

Islam

Israeli daily aggression on the Palestinian people 

Media Watch

Mission and meaning of Al-Jazeerah

News Photos

Poetry

Public Announcements 

   Public Activities 

Women in News

 

 

 

 

Russian special forces storm theater: Bloody ending of hostage crisis

Ananova, 10/26/02

 

Russian special forces have freed all of the captives held at a Moscow theatre by Chechen rebels. At least 20 bodies were seen being taken from the theatre after a night of explosions and gunfire. Some of the bodies were hostages, Russian news agencies say. The leader of the rebels was also killed.

A spokesman for the Federal Security Service says most of the hostage takers have been killed. He added that the operation to free the hostages began when the Chechen rebels began executing the captives. Russian authorities are searching for any hostage-takers who might be hiding in the building. 

Earlier, officials said two hostages were killed and two injured and that the hostage-takers had begun to kill their captives. Two women escaped as soldiers armed with assault rifles were seen moving towards the theatre, and two more ran from the building later.

The hostage-takers had earlier threatened to begin killing their captives before sunrise. After the two deaths, officials reached the captors by phone but then quickly said their negotiations had failed. 

Movsar Barayev - a nephew of Arbi Barayev - led the group of as many as 50 heavily armed Chechen men and women into the theatre in a bold raid on Wednesday night.

 

Russian Forces Control Theater

Russian News Net, 10/26/02

 

MOSCOW (AP) -- Special forces troops stormed a Moscow theater before sunrise Saturday, freeing hundreds of hostages held by Chechen rebels and killing their leader in a bloody end to the three-day standoff.

Dozens of bodies were seen being removed from the theater. Survivors were loaded onto buses, many in shock or unconscious.

Deputy Interior Minister Vladimir Vasilyev said that about three dozen of the estimated 50 hostage-takers had been killed, but that some apparently had managed to escape. It was unclear how many of the more than 600 hostages were killed.

He added that by storming the building, special forces avoided greater casualties and ``the death of most of the hostages, including children.''

The rescue raid was launched after the rebels began executing captives, said Sergei Ignatchenko, a spokesman for the Federal Security Service.

The rebels, who stormed the building Wednesday and later said they would start executing hostages if Russia did not end its war in the republic of Chechnya, had reportedly mined the stage and aisles and placed a bomb in the center of the theater. Some rebels were seen in television footage wearing explosive belts and said they were ready for martyrdom.

``Those kamikazes who threatened to blow themselves up were unable to,'' Vasilyev said.

President Vladimir Putin was informed and was following developments, Russian news agencies reported.

The assault Saturday came after a night of heavy explosions and repeated bursts of gunfire.

Earlier, officials said two hostages were killed and two injured before the special forces moved in. Two women escaped as soldiers armed with assault rifles were seen moving toward the theater, and two more ran from the building later while ambulances poured into the southeast Moscow neighborhood where the crisis began Wednesday evening.

The hostage-takers had earlier threatened to begin killing their captives before sunrise Saturday. After the two deaths, officials reached the captors by phone but then quickly said their negotiations had failed.

Late Friday, a mediator who met with the gunmen said they promised to release the hostages if Putin declared an end to the war in Chechnya and began withdrawing troops.

The new demands were brought out of the theater just before midnight Friday by Anna Politkovskaya, a Russian journalist who is respected by Chechens for her reporting on the war and was called in by the rebels to mediate.

Politkovskaya said the gunmen had told her they were ``going to wait only a little while'' before they started killing hostages.

She listed rebel demands, and foremost among them were Putin's declaration of an end to the war and the start of a Russian withdrawal from one region anywhere in Chechnya to show good will. If verified, the rebels promised to free the hostages.

She said the captors agreed to her suggestion that verification be done by Lord Judd, a member of the Council of Europe who has made many trips to investigate the human rights situation in Chechnya.

The demand was the first time that the gunmen revealed specific conditions for freeing the hostages, estimated to number as many as 800 and include Americans, Britons, Dutch, Australians, Canadians, Austrians and Germans. Earlier, the captors demanded that Russia withdraw from Chechnya.

Putin said Friday that ``the preservation of the lives of the people who remain in the theater building'' was his overriding concern. Federal Security Service chief Nikolai Patrushev said after meeting with Putin that the hostage-takers' lives would be guaranteed if they freed their captives.

The heavily armed hostage-takers had said they were ready to die and take their hostages with them if their demands weren't met, and witnesses said they had wired the building and themselves with explosives.

 

 


 

Israeli troops take over Jenin
Arab News

OCCUPIED JERUSALEM, 26 October — Israel took over the Palestinian town of Jenin yesterday in one of the largest raids since the summer but pulled some troops out of another West Bank town, Hebron. The Jenin raid and the redeployment in Hebron came as a US envoy, Assistant Secretary of State William Burns, wrapped up talks with skeptical Israelis and Palestinians on a new Mideast peace plan that envisions a provisional Palestinian state by 2003 and full independence by 2005. In a very public snub of Yasser Arafat, Burns held talks with a Palestinian legislator only a few yards from the Palestinian leader’s headquarters in the West Bank town of Ramallah. The United States has been boycotting Arafat, saying he has broken promises to rein in hard-liners. Arafat called the incursion a "crime," and his aides said the United States must put a stop to such strikes if it wants to be a credible mediator. Before dawn , hundreds of soldiers, backed by tanks, entered Jenin and the adjacent refugee camp, imposed a curfew and took over more than 30 buildings, residents said.



 

Russia, France float own UN Iraq drafts

Arab News

UNITED NATIONS, 26 October — In a surprise move, Russia and France yesterday began circulating proposals to significantly water-down a US draft resolution on Iraq, removing language that could authorize military force against Baghdad and limiting inspections on presidential sites. Both Russia and France have strongly opposed elements of the US draft and six weeks of negotiations failed to win them over.

The introduction of rival proposals was seen as the opening salvo in a new round of negotiations, which diplomats said are likely to continue into next week.

The United States countered by formally submitting its text to the Security Council to ensure it was the basis for discussions. The French and Russian proposals could also be introduced, but the US move meant its resolution would likely be voted on first.

The Russia text was more stridently opposed to the US draft resolution, while diplomats close to the negotiations said the French paper tried to bridge the American and Russian drafts in an effort to reach consensus within the Security Council.

"I think it shows that they’re genuinely trying to conduct a negotiation," said Britain’s UN Ambassador Jeremy Greenstock. Both the Russian and French texts eliminate references in the US draft to Iraq being in "material breach" for violating UN resolutions, a phrase some legal experts say could open the door for military action. The Russian text also removes a US warning of "serious consequences" if Iraq doesn’t comply with UN weapons inspections.

The competing drafts were circulated to Security Council members ahead of a new round of discussions at a closed Council meeting on the US text. Council diplomats said the United States intended to collect views from the 15 members and then look at the next steps, not negotiate.

US President George W. Bush asked Chinese President Jiang Zemin to back the US draft resolution. "China supports Iraq’s strict compliance with UN Security Council resolutions," Bush told reporters after meeting Jiang at his Texas ranch. "And today ... I urged President Jiang to support a new Security Council resolution demanding Iraq fully disarm itself of weapons of mass destruction."

Bush said he would reject any resolution that curtails his ability to take military action to disarm Iraq if the United Nations failed to do so. "We won’t accept a resolution which prevents us from doing exactly what I have told the American people is going to happen, and that is if the UN won’t act, and if Saddam won’t disarm, we will lead a coalition to disarm him."

Iraqi Foreign Minister Naji Sabri on Thursday likened the US draft to a declaration of war and said Iraq had worked in good faith and agreed to let UN inspectors back without any conditions.



 

Islamists score victory in Bahrain poll

Arab News

MANAMA, 26 October — Results from Bahrain’s first legislative elections in nearly 30 years showed a mix of Islamist and secular candidates winning seats, with two women securing places in run-off polls, officials said yesterday.

The election was a milestone for women as it marked the first time they had been empowered to vote and run for national office in the Gulf region. It was also a defeat for a boycott campaign that had argued the political reform process did not go far enough.

The Justice Ministry said that 19 candidates had been elected to the 40-seat Parliament, including three who ran unopposed. The remaining 21 seats will be decided in run-off elections scheduled for Oct. 31.

The elections themselves were celebrated as a major step toward democracy in Bahrain. Hundreds of Bahrainis drove around the capital in the early hours yesterday after Information Minister Nabil Al-Hamer said the turnout was 53.2 percent, a slight improvement on the 51 percent recorded in the municipal elections in May.

The United States was quick to applaud Bahrain’s first legislative elections since the 1975 dissolution of a parliament elected only two years earlier. "We applaud Bahrain’s commitment to political reform and we strongly encourage the Bahraini government to continue down this path," State Department spokesman Gregg Sullivan said.

Ali Salman, the leader of the Al-Wefaq National Islamic Society that spearheaded the boycott call, conceded yesterday that the elections were "fair overall."

"I congratulate the king on this democratic initiative," Salman said, said on the phone from Qatar, where he flew yesterday morning for a television broadcast.

Salman, however, cast doubt on the accuracy of the 53.2 percent turnout, saying he had expected a turnout of 25 percent and his group’s monitors had estimated it to be about 40 percent.

Salman said the electorate had been influenced by the king, who appealed to citizens to vote in a televised address on Monday. He also thought the turnout had been reinforced by "allowing the military to participate and by stamping the passports of Bahrainis who voted."

He said the stamping of passports, used as identification, had "put psychological pressure on the citizens to participate."

The authorities were jubilant over the perceived rebuff to the four opposition groups which had called for the boycott.

People took to the streets of Manama blaring car horns and waving national flags and posters of the king, Sheikh Hamad ibn Issa Al-Khalifa.

"This is a victory for our nation," said Hadi Al-Naem, a pedestrian who cheered the passing cars.

It was difficult to say whether secular or Islamist candidates were in the majority of the 19 elected legislators as most are new faces whose views are not known outside their districts. However, a leading analyst and political columnist, Mahdi Rabe’a of Al-Ayam newspaper, said yesterday that at least 10 of the winners were Islamists and the rest were secular politicians.

He said the Islamists belonged mainly to the groups Al-Asalah and Al-Menber Al-Islami, which are Sunni-dominated.

Sunnis form a slight minority of Bahrain’s 400,000 citizens and include the royal family among their members.

The fact that the boycott campaign was dominated by the majority Shiites has impeded their representation in the new Parliament, Rabe’a said.

The winners and potential winners include the heads of three Sunni political groups. Adel Adel Al-Muawda of Al-Asala and Salah Ali of the National Islamic Forum were elected in the first round, while Al-Shoura chief Abdul Rahman Abdul Salam seems assured of victory in the run-off. Seventeen other Islamists have a good chance of coming out on top in a runoff slated for Oct. 31. Most of them are well ahead of their nearest rivals.

The government has said it is not concerned about an Islamist victory. "We are all Muslim so I am not afraid of that," said Bahrain’s Crown Prince Sheikh Salman ibn Hamad Al-Khalifa.

Analysts said the onus was now on the government and the opposition to work together to ensure adequate representation for both main sects, despite the lack of mainstream Shiite parties in Parliament.

"The boycott weakened Parliament and was a golden opportunity for inexperienced candidates," said Bahraini analyst Jassim Hussein. "Now we have a house where 47 percent of the people are not represented. This is a negative development."

No woman won outright in Thursday’s polls, but two females are among the 42 candidates who will contest the run-offs.

The women who won places in the run-offs were Latifa Al-Qaoud, who seeks to represent a southern province, and Fouzia Ahmed Ruwaie, from a northern province.

Al-Qaoud, 46, is a single woman who heads the planning and development department in the Ministry of Finance. She holds an MBA degree from Nottingham University in Britain and pledged to uplift the status of Bahraini women.

The new assembly, which has a four-year mandate, is expected to hold its first session in December after the king appoints the 40-member upper house.



 

Occupation forces kill another child

US envoy warns Palestinians no state without end to violence

Jordan Times, 10/26/02

 

JERICHO (AFP) — US Middle East envoy William Burns on Thursday told the Palestinians they will only achieve statehood through ending “violence” and overhauling their administration, as Israeli occupation forces shot dead another Palestinian child in the West Bank.

Ahmad Jafar, 13, died after being hit in the chest when a crowd of Palestinian youths pelted an Israeli armoured column with stones, as around 20 Israeli vehicles entered the northern town of Jenin, Palestinian officials said.

Meanwhile Burns, on a Middle East tour to push an international peace “road map,” said Washington “wants to end the very real suffering and humiliation that the Palestinians experience every day.”

But he stressed progress would only come if the Palestinian National Authority turned tough on resistance groups and carried out thorough reforms of its administration, accused of corruption and supporting militants.

“I emphasise finally that it is only through the decisive action to end terror and violence, and decisive action on reform in preparation for Palestinian statehood that we will be able to move forward on a practical pathway to end the occupation and this terrible conflict,” he said.

President Yasser Arafat was glaringly absent from the meeting, as part of US and Israeli efforts to sideline the Palestinian leader, viewed by both as an obstacle to peace.

He is due to unveil a new cabinet next week, after parliament rejected his previous reshuffle, carried out under intense domestic and international pressure.

Burns also held talks with Israeli Defence Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer and had a closed-door meeting with Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, who has given his plan a chilly reception.

Right-wing Sharon said Israel would be asked “to concede too much” of occupied Palestinian lands with no guarantees that the Palestinians would “reciprocate”.

The Palestinian delegation was led by chief negotiator Saeb Erekat, who said he himself would meet later in occupied Jerusalem with Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres to discuss relieving the situation of the Palestinian people.

But Erekat appeared to also react coolly to the US envoy's visit, making clear he was not happy at the US boycott of Arafat.

“The Americans have to see president Arafat, and this is a mistake, but president Arafat insists we have to give peace a chance,” he said.

While refusing to comment directly on the US draft of the roadmap, he said: “I can see this plan is full of conditions.”

He said Arafat and the Palestinian leadership would study it before giving any official reaction.

Burns is trying to convince both sides to back a plan put together by the so-called Middle East quartet of Washington, the United Nations, European Union and Russia, which calls for an independent Palestinian state to be formed in three years.

“This is just a draft and we will express our reservations on certain points,” said an official from the Israeli prime minister's office, who asked not to be named.

He said “there is no question of the Israeli army making the least pullback (from Palestinian territories) as the plan sets out until the Palestinian Authority decided to fight terrorists from Islamic Jihad and Hamas (another Islamic resistance group fighting Israeli occupation) and we see some results on the ground.”

He stressed that the timetable in the plan, for a Palestinian state without fixed borders by next year, “doesn't appear realistic, even supposing the Palestinians do decide to act immediately against terrorism, which they have not done until now.”

The Israeli official also voiced serious doubts about “the credibility of proposed supervision of the implementation of the quartet plan.”

“It is difficult to leave it up to the European Union when EU officials recently held contacts with Hamas and Islamic Jihad to end terrorism in Israel and not in Judea and Samaria (the West Bank) and Gaza, as though there was a legitimate form of terrorism,” he said.

But in an apparent softening of its position, Islamic Jihad's head Ramadan Abdallah Shallah told the Arabic-language daily Al Hayat that his militants could cease attacks on civilians if Israel does so as well.

“If they (Israelis) are ready to stop killing (Palestinian) civilians and to stop the massacres they commit, we are ready to revise our policy of Jihad,” or holy war, he said.

“If they want this, they must take the initiative, but we are not going to beg them,” he said, in an interview given shortly after a car bomb attack claimed by Islamic Jihad on a bus in northern Israel on Monday killed at least 13 people, plus the two bombers.

Shallah added that Islamic Jihad's “strategic objective is the total liberation of Palestine,” which includes the territories on which Israel was established in 1948.

 


 

Excerpts of new US draft peace plan for Middle East

Jordan Times, 10/26/02 
 

THESE ARE excerpts from a draft of a new Middle East peace plan formulated by the so-called Quartet of mediators — the United States, the United Nations, the European Union and Russia. The document, obtained by the Associated Press, has been presented to Israel and the Palestinians by a visiting US envoy.

Phase I: October 2002-May 2003

First Stage: October-December 2002

Appointment of new Palestinian cabinet, establishment of empowered prime minister, including any necessary Palestinian legal reforms for this purpose.

Palestinian leadership issues unequivocal statement reiterating Israel's right to exist in peace and security and calling for an immediate end to the armed Intifada and all acts of violence against Israelis anywhere.

Palestinian security organisations are consolidated into three services reporting to an empowered interior minister.

Government of Israel ends actions undermining trust, including attacks in civilian areas, and confiscation/demolition of Palestinian homes/property, deportations as a punitive measure or to facilitate Israeli construction.

Government of Israel dismantles settlement outposts erected since the establishment of the present Israeli government and in contravention of current Israeli government guidelines.

Second Stage: January-May 2003

As comprehensive security performance moves forward, Israeli Defence Forces withdraw progressively from areas occupied since Sept. 28, 2000. Withdrawal to be completed before holding of Palestinian elections. Palestinian security forces redeploy to areas vacated by the IDF.

Palestinians and Israelis conclude a new security agreement building upon Tenet work plan, including an effective security mechanism and an end to violence, terrorism and incitement, implemented through a restructured and effective Palestinian security service.

Government of Israel freezes all settlement activity consistent with the Mitchell report, including natural growth of settlements.

Palestinians hold free, open and fair elections for Palestinian Legislative Council.

Phase II: June 2003-December 2003 (Transition)

Progress into Phase II will be based on judgement of the Quartet, faciliated by the establishment of a permanent monitoring mechanism on the ground, whether conditions are appropriate to move on — taking into account performance of all parties and Quartet monitoring. Phase II starts after Palestinian elections and ends with the possible creation of a Palestinian state with provisional borders by end of 2003.

International Conference: Convened by the Quartet, in agreement with the parties, immediately after the successful conclusion of Palestinian elections to support Palestinian economic recovery and launch negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians on the possibility of a state with provisional borders.

Conclusion of transitional understanding and creation of a state with provisional borders by end of 2003. Enhanced international role in monitoring transition.

Further action on settlements simultaneous with establishment of Palestinian state with provisional borders.

Phase III: 2004-2005 (Statehood)

Progress into Phase III, based on judgement of the Quartet, taking into account actions of all parties and Quartet monitoring.

Second International Conference: Convened by the Quartet, with agreement of the parties, at beginning of 2004 to endorse agreement reached on state with provisional borders and to launch negotiations between Israel and Palestinians towards a final, permanent status resolution in 2005, including on borders, Jerusalem, refugees and settlements; and to support progress toward a comprehensive Middle East settlement between Israel and Lebanon and Syria, to be achieved as soon as possible.

Arab state acceptance of normal relations with Israel and security for all the states in the region, consistent with Beirut Arab Summit initiative.

 


 

Iraq accused United States of steering Iraqi diplomats into 'betraying their country'

Jordan Times, 10/26/02 
 

BAGHDAD (AP) — Iraq's foreign minister accused the United States on Thursday of trying to lure key Iraqi diplomats negotiating the return of arms inspectors into defecting from the government of President Saddam Hussein.

“In blatant operations ... American embassy and intelligence officials were contacting members of the Iraqi delegation in an attempt to lure them into betraying their country,” Naji Sabri told the Arab satellite channel Al Jazeera in an interview.

He said he was referring to the delegations at the United Nations, where diplomats are negotiating a new resolution to send the inspectors back, and Vienna, Austria, where UN nuclear weapons inspectors have their headquarters.

In the past, in high-profile defections of Iraqi diplomats, the United States has refused to comment on any role it may have played. In July 2001, when two Iraqis at the United Nations requested US asylum, State Department spokesman Richard Boucher said “we don't discuss alleged asylum requests.”

However, Western intelligence officials and Iraqi dissidents have told the Associated Press in Cairo, Egypt, that British and American officials have approached Iraqi diplomats at international gatherings to talk about defecting to the Iraqi opposition. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity.

Since Iraq's 1990 invasion of Kuwait, dozens of Iraqi diplomats have defected to Arab or Western countries, and several joined opposition groups. The defections, some by former government ministers and senior figures in the ruling Baath party, have been an embarrassment to President Saddam's government.

Sabri also said the new US draft resolution on the arms inspectors' return would block Iraq from dealing directly with the inspectors on any problem, instructing the inspectors to refer even the smallest snag, such as getting stuck in a traffic, to the UN Security Council.

“Traffic jams ... constitute a threat to international peace and security,” he said.

The new US draft would destroy the prestige of the United Nations by trying to create a pretext for a US attack on Iraq through the resolution, Sabri said.

“This is a draft law to take control of and declare war on the United Nations,” he told Al Jazeera.

The US proposal, drafted with British support, gives UN inspectors broad new powers to search and destroy material related to weapons of mass destruction and warns Iraq of “serious consequences” if it obstructs their work.

Russia already has argued against the draft resolution, argue it could trigger military action. Washington has sought to put a so-called automatic trigger in the resolution should Iraq obstruct the inspectors, but France has argued a second resolution would have to be adopted before war could be undertaken.

The UN arms inspectors were pulled out of Baghdad in 1998 just before the United States and Britain carried out bombing raids to punish Iraq for blocking the inspectors from doing their jobs.

The inspectors had the job of certifying that Iraq was free of weapons of mass destruction under Security Council resolutions adopted after the Iraqi army invaded neighboring Kuwait in 1990.

The resolutions required Iraq to eliminate all its chemical, biological and nuclear weapons and means to manufacture those arms. Iraq maintains it has fulfilled the terms of the resolutions.

Iraq's state-controlled media on Thursday also railed against the American draft plan setting guidelines for return of the inspectors.

“Security Council members are urged to take a firm stance against the latest US cheap maneuvers to rig the UN resolutions so that they fit America's wishes and aggressive plans,” the daily Al Jumhuriya in a front page editorial.

 

 

 


http://www.aljazeerah.info

Opinions expressed in various sections are the sole responsibility of their authors and they may not represent Al-Jazeerah's.